Note: This is not an application by any means With the Oldtown server build approaching I would like to adress the possibility of having Brightwater Keep and Florent lands be allowed a redo. I belive that all three categories of requirements for a redo are somewhat met by the project. The keep should suffer the same fate as Blackcrown and Threetowers who were both destroyed as to allow them to be better incorporated in the OT "belt" of houses. As it stands this project is surrounded by newer terraforming and projects. It does not match in style with Bandallon, Honeyholt or the Oldtown region. It feels more fitting for the Vale visually. This quote is from the Clash of Kings apendix: While the keep is proper for such a big and powerful house in size, there is a lack of fields and sources of income for such a great house withing the reach. The only noteworthy location in the lands is the small market town of Greenmarket and it does not have anything outsanding. Furthermore the market town isn't really visually a major trading hub and dosen't have a large market area. From our wiki: As said,the town itself dosen't feel like a trade center aside for the smallish docks that can house two barges. It is hard to portray them as a powerful house of the reach when their lands are so bare. This image also depicts a vast area of unused land north of the keep: Also another issue that arises with this project is the narrow bridge passage and that there are wider barges up river: Barge 1 Barge 2 The project has incomplete elements: (A) (B) In conclusion, aside that the project dates from 2014 making it hard to blend in with the newer projects that literally surround it, there are canon issues about the house's standing within the ASOIAF universe in regards to how the lands portray their standing. There are technical issues with the river and the bridge, the market town is not finished and most importantly there are doubts of how this project will integrate with OT in the future. Hope this helps put in perspective why some of us think Brightwaterkeep should be allowed aredo under our no redos rules.